Wives Earning More Than Husbands Linked to an Increase in Mental Health Diagnoses for Both Partners, Study Finds

What happens when long-standing family traditions meet modern economic realities? As gender roles shift and women increasingly step into the role of primary earners, the dynamics within households are transforming. But at what cost? A study from The Economic Journal uncovers a striking correlation: when wives outearn their husbands, both partners experience a higher likelihood of mental health issues.

Couple Fighting

Couple Fighting

This isn’t just about numbers; it’s about identity, societal expectations, and the challenges of adapting to change. Are couples equipped to handle these evolving roles, or is the strain proving too much?

The Study: What Did It Find?

Dr. Demid Getik’s research looked into this emerging issue by examining Swedish couples over a decade. Using administrative data, the study explored how income distribution within marriages impacts mental health. Here’s what the study showed:

  1. A Surprising Spike in Diagnoses: When wives earned more than their husbands, the likelihood of mental health diagnoses jumped by 8% overall and by 11% for men.
  2. Gendered Patterns:
    • Men: Substance-related disorders (drinking alcohol and taking drugs) were most common, hinting at struggles to reconcile traditional gender roles.
    • Women: Neurotic and stress-related conditions dominated, likely fueled by the pressures of career and home life.

The research links mental health outcomes directly to changes in relative income, not to broader life events like divorce or workplace stress.

What do these findings mean for equality? Do traditional narratives still influence dynamics, even in egalitarian societies?

Changing the Rules of the Game

The study paints a picture of a global trend: the rise of women as primary earners. In both Sweden and the United States, the percentage of households where wives earn more has risen by 25% since the early 2000s. While this shift is often celebrated as progress, it also disrupts long-held beliefs about family roles.

What does it mean to be a husband today? For many men, the breadwinner identity remains deeply ingrained. Losing that role can feel like a personal failure, leading to stress, anxiety, and even substance use. On the other hand, women who take on the financial lead often face societal expectations to still “do it all” to excel at work, manage the household, and raise children.

Is it fair to expect individuals to adapt to such seismic changes without adequate support?

The Data Behind the Story

Dr. Getik used detailed data from multiple Swedish registers to draw these conclusions:

  • Population and Income Data: Married couples were tracked from 2001, with annual income data identifying when wives began outearning their husbands.
  • Mental Health Diagnoses: Using the National Patient Register, the study analyzed clinical diagnoses, focusing on conditions like anxiety, depression, and substance use disorders.
  • Workplace Insights: Data from the Workplace Register offered a glimpse into professional environments, though no strong workplace effects were observed.

The methodology allowed researchers to pinpoint a key threshold: the moment a wife’s income surpassed her husband’s and tracked its mental health impact.

Could this tipping point symbolize more than just a financial shift? Perhaps it’s a psychological and emotional reckoning, forcing couples to confront deeply rooted beliefs about their roles.

Why Does This Matter?

The findings reveal much more than economic trends. They expose the hidden costs of progress:

  1. For Men: The loss of the breadwinner role can trigger identity crises. Substance-related disorders, which showed the sharpest increase, suggest coping mechanisms that may not address the underlying emotional strain.
  2. For Women: Balancing societal expectations with new responsibilities often leads to stress-related conditions. Urban, educated women were particularly affected, possibly because they face even greater societal scrutiny.

What happens when we don’t address these struggles? Are we leaving couples to navigate uncharted territory without a map?

The Bigger Picture

These findings raise critical questions about how we approach gender equality and family dynamics. Are we underestimating the psychological toll of progress? How can society better support couples as they adapt to these changes?

Employers, policymakers, and mental health professionals have a role to play:

  • Employers: Create workplaces that value diverse family dynamics and provide resources for work-life balance.
  • Policymakers: Develop mental health programs tailored to the unique challenges of modern families.
  • Couples: Foster open communication to address anxieties and redefine shared goals.

Is it time to rethink the “ideal family”? Instead of clinging to outdated norms, can we create new models that celebrate partnership over tradition?

FAQs

Does the study apply only to Sweden?
While the study used Swedish data, the findings may be relevant to other countries with similar economic and social trends.

Are men more affected than women?
Yes, men showed an 11% increase in mental health diagnoses, compared to an 8% increase overall.

What types of mental health issues were observed?
Men commonly experienced substance-related disorders, while women were more prone to stress and anxiety disorders.

Is divorce a factor in the mental health diagnoses?
No, the study found no strong link between these diagnoses and divorce.

Why are urban and educated women more affected?
This group may face higher societal expectations, increasing stress when balancing work and family roles.

Can workplace environments explain these outcomes?
No, workplace dynamics did not significantly influence the observed mental health trends.

What is the key takeaway from this study?
Changes in income dynamics, particularly when wives earn more than their husbands, can impact mental health for both partners.

What can couples do to manage these challenges?
Open communication and seeking support can help address role-related stress and improve relationship dynamics.

Final Thoughts

Change is rarely smooth, and this study shows the complexities of evolving family roles. As women continue to break barriers, the ripple effects on relationships, identity, and mental health are profound.

What does this mean for the future of families? Can we embrace equality without neglecting the emotional and psychological adjustments it demands?

The study’s findings are both a warning and a call to action. If we truly value progress, society must address its hidden costs and provide the tools couples need to thrive.

In the end, it’s not just about who earns more it’s about creating partnerships that withstand the pressures of modern life. By supporting each other through these transitions, couples can redefine what success and happiness look like.

References

Demid Getik, Relative Income and Mental Health in Couples, The Economic Journal, Volume 134, Issue 664, November 2024, Pages 3291–3305, https://doi.org/10.1093/ej/ueae071

FEEDBACK:

Want to live your best life?

Get the Gilmore Health Weekly newsletter for health tips, wellness updates and more.

By clicking "Subscribe," I agree to the Gilmore Health and . I also agree to receive emails from Gilmore Health and I understand that I may opt out of Gilmore Health subscriptions at any time.