Semantic memory, which encompasses our knowledge about facts and concepts, is known to be relatively stable as we age. However, in the early stages of neurodegenerative diseases, such as mild cognitive impairment (MCI), a decline in semantic memory is noticeable. A study titled “Differences in EEG oscillations between normal aging and mild cognitive impairment during semantic memory retrieval” delves into the electroencephalography (EEG) oscillatory correlates of semantic memory retrieval, exploring the effects of both normal and pathological aging.
EEG
Key Findings and Methodology
Participants:
- Young Adults (YA): 29 participants, mean age 21.3.
- Healthy Aging Adults (HA): 22 participants, mean age 63.9.
- Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) Patients: 20 participants, mean age 67.8.
Semantic Memory and Aging:
- Semantic memory is generally preserved with normal cognitive aging but declines in the early stages of Alzheimer’s disease and related dementia (AD-RD), including MCI.
- Healthy older adults may experience challenges with word retrieval but maintain semantic knowledge, while those with MCI and AD-RD may experience semantic memory deficits.
Semantic Object Retrieval Test (SORT):
- Participants were asked to judge whether two words (features of objects) led to the retrieval of an object (retrieval) or not (non-retrieval).
- The task examines access to semantic knowledge without requiring overt word retrieval, ideal for investigating changes in semantic memory retrieval associated with normal versus pathological aging.
Read Also: Discovery Might Have Major Implications for the Regeneration of Aging Brains in Healthy Persons
EEG Analysis:
- EEG, with its millisecond temporal resolution, was used to study neural dynamics associated with semantic memory.
- The study examined oscillatory dynamics in theta, alpha, and high/low beta frequency bands during the SORT.
- The aim was to explore differences in EEG event-related oscillatory power changes during SORT, compared to younger adults, with no evident differences in behavioral performance measured by accuracy and reaction time.
Discussion: Semantic Memory and Aging Implications
Semantic Memory Stability and Decline
Normal Aging: While semantic memory predominantly retains stability during the aging process, subtle challenges, particularly in the domain of word retrieval, are observed among older adults. Despite these challenges, the repository of semantic knowledge largely remains intact, facilitating fundamental coherence and consistency in knowledge and understanding. Moreover, the employment of additional neural resources compared to younger counterparts suggests a compensatory mechanism that enables the preservation of semantic memory functionality amidst biological aging.
Pathological Aging: In contrast, adults with MCI and AD-RD present a different trajectory. The semantic memory deficits observed in this demographic extend beyond mere retrieval issues and may embody a more pervasive and systemic degradation of semantic knowledge. Here, the deficits are not merely a function of retrieval failure but suggest a potential erosion of the knowledge base itself. This distinction, pivotal in differentiating normal aging from pathological aging, underscores the criticality of discerning the nature and extent of semantic memory deficits among older adults.
Read Also: Building a Better Aging Brain: Exploring Scaffolding Theory and Cognitive Health
Neural Dynamics, Memory Retrieval, and Aging
Young vs. Aging Adults: The study sought to elucidate the differences in neural activities between younger and older adults during semantic memory retrieval. Specifically, variations in EEG event-related oscillatory power changes during the SORT task were analyzed. Insights reveal that the aging brain employs adaptive neural mechanisms, exhibiting a distinctive yet proficient strategy for maintaining and retrieving semantic memories in the context of healthy aging. Thus, the differences observed in EEG oscillations between the age groups offer valuable perspectives into how aging impacts neural strategies engaged in semantic memory retrieval processes.
Healthy Aging vs. MCI: Analyzing the EEG patterns of cognitively normal older adults and those with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) reveals clear differences aligned with the observable behavioral and cognitive variances between these groups. Specifically, MCI patients exhibited reduced accuracy in retrieval tasks and changes in EEG oscillatory power, indicating disparities in both behavior and neural activity. This detailed insight offers a valuable perspective, enhancing our ability to develop early detection and intervention strategies for MCI, which may help slow down its progression to more severe stages of Alzheimer’s Disease and Related dementia (AD-RD).
Read Also: Julich Brain Atlas Could Advance Study of Psychiatric and Aging Disorders
Bridging Behavioral and Neural Analyses
Behavioral Performance and Neural Mechanisms: The congruence, or lack thereof, between behavioral performance and neural mechanisms during semantic memory retrieval across different aging cohorts prompts a deeper exploration into how these elements interface within the aging process. Recognizing the loci where behavioral performance and neural mechanisms diverge provides an avenue to explore potential intervention points to bolster semantic memory amidst aging and cognitive decline.
Questions and Insights
Understanding EEG Oscillations: How do EEG oscillations provide insights into the neural mechanisms underlying semantic memory retrieval, and how might these insights inform strategies for early detection of pathological aging?
SORT and Semantic Memory: Given the SORT paradigm’s ability to examine access to semantic knowledge without requiring overt word retrieval, how might this approach be utilized or adapted in future research to further explore the nuances of semantic memory retrieval across different stages of aging and cognitive impairment?
Pathological Aging and Cognitive Impairment: Considering the observed EEG patterns and behavioral differences in MCI patients compared to healthy aging adults, how might these findings inform the development of diagnostic tools or interventions aimed at mitigating the impact of pathological aging on semantic memory?
Read Also: Early L-Dopa Administration for Age-Related Cognitive Decline and Dementia Harmful
Final Thoughts
The exploration of EEG oscillations in relation to semantic memory retrieval across different aging stages provides a rich avenue for understanding the neural mechanisms underlying cognitive aging and impairment. The findings from this study pave the way for further research into the nuanced changes in neural dynamics associated with semantic memory retrieval, potentially informing the development of diagnostic and intervention strategies for conditions like MCI and AD-RD. Future research might delve deeper into understanding the specific neural pathways and mechanisms implicated in these observed EEG oscillatory changes and explore how these findings might be translated into practical applications for enhancing cognitive health and mitigating the impacts of pathological aging.
References
Chiang, H.-S., Lydon, E. A., Kraut, M. A., Hart, J. Jr, & Mudar, R. A. (2023). Differences in electroencephalography oscillations between normal aging and mild cognitive impairment during semantic memory retrieval. European Journal of Neuroscience, 58(1), 2278-2296. https://doi.org/10.1111/ejn.16001
